Cagle Auction Co. | The South’s Most Trusted Auction

1850s Edgefield South Carolina Face Jug Marked Y. $54,000 World Record

The South’s Most Trusted Auction

Now Accepting Quality Consignments!!

When choosing an auction house to consign your items, remember this:

Cagle Auction holds more world records for Southern Pottery than any other auction firm.

Cagle Auction Company is a full service auction with over 20 plus years in the business. Our focus is on researching items and our vast knowledge of southern pottery and stoneware, primitives, gas and oil signs, Coca Cola memorabilia and soda advertising, Americana, antiques, firearms, coins, stamps and many other collectibles.

We specialize in on-site estate auctions realizing top dollar for your items. We are always on the lookout for quality items to consign in our sales so don’t hesitate to reach out to us with all of your auction needs. We take a lot of pride in taking care of you and your special merchandise whether it’s one piece, a few pieces or a whole estate. We are here to bring you quality items and build a lasting relationship.

J.S Nash decorated face jug. Highest price ever paid for Texas stoneware. $77,000 World Record

      EXCELLENT  
   Based on 20 reviews 
    
 
 
 
   
 
 
       Posted on Google  
   
   thehayman2 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Had very good experiences with them. They are great with! Thanks
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Jan Goswick 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I am a passionate collector of Edgefield stoneware and cannot recommend Cagle Auction highly enough! As many collectors know, Edgefield pottery has become increasingly difficult to find due to its age and the growing number of collectors seeking it. Most of the pieces I acquire come through auctions, and while a handful of reputable auction houses regularly feature Edgefield stoneware, they are not conveniently located for me in Lexington, SC. The closest is nearly two hours away, with most being closer to four. For those unfamiliar, one trademark of Edgefield pottery is the significant weight of the pieces. As a result, shipping costs can often approach the price of the piece itself. Because of the distance and logistics, I typically participate in auctions online and rarely have the opportunity to preview items in person. This makes it absolutely critical for the auction house to provide honest and accurate descriptions of both the piece and its condition. Unfortunately, I have experienced disappointing transactions with other auction houses where items were not accurately described. However, that has never been the case with Cagle Auction. I completely trust the descriptions and assessments provided, which speaks volumes about the professionalism and integrity of Brandon and his team. What sets Cagle Auction apart even further is Brandon’s deep personal knowledge and passion for Southern stoneware. He is not simply an auctioneer; he is a dedicated collector and expert, capable of attributing pieces to specific makers. If he does not know the maker, he is honest about it or consults his network of collectors and historians. On several occasions, Brandon has even helped me identify makers of pieces in my personal collection, including items not purchased through Cagle which demonstrates an extraordinary level of service that truly sets Cagle apart. Over the years, I’ve built friendships with many fellow collectors, and I can say without hesitation that most of us are hardworking, middle-class individuals who have developed a love for collecting pottery… a pursuit that can be quite expensive and only continues to become more so. It is extremely frustrating to invest in a piece, only to find it misrepresented upon arrival. We don't have money to waste; we work hard and save carefully to continue growing our collections. I am grateful to Brandon and Cagle Auction for their commitment to transparency, accuracy, and customer care. One example that highlights this dedication: In a recent online-only auction, I won a piece that would have cost nearly $200 to ship. Without me even asking, Brandon made arrangements with a fellow collector who happened to live near me and was attending an upcoming event, to transport the piece back, saving me the shipping costs. While it was fortunate that the timing and circumstances aligned, the most important takeaway is that Brandon knew enough about his customers and proactively went out of his way to help me out and save me a lot of money. Thank you, Brandon and Cagle Auction, for consistently demonstrating expertise, transparency, and genuine care for both the pieces and the collectors who cherish them.  I will be a forever customer and cannot wait until your next auction!!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Isaac Rizor 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Cagle Auction is the real deal.. great items and a great service. Shipping was very secure and packaging was great. 10/10
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Stephen 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Following my recent first purchase through Cagle Auction, I have nothing but good things to say about the process and the outcome.
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Jimmy Martin 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. It was awesome meeting you today. I really appreciate you taking the time to show me around and share insights about your business and your personal collections. I enjoyed your auction  experience a lot. I’m looking forward to connecting again!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Daniel Davis 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Cagle auction was a wonderful experience they gave me information about my items history and saved me a lot on shipping cost by taking to ups and packaging for me. A 5 star experience!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   wade watkins 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Simply the best, hands down the greatest customer service I've ever experienced, and the results exceeded all my expectations! The owner of Cagle Auction Company, Brandon Pratt, flew from Atlanta to Dallas on New Years Day 2023 to take a look at a piece of stoneware pottery I had posted on an internet forum. He rented a car and drove almost three hours to meet me and view the piece of pottery with no guarantee that it would go to his auction house for consignment. We went to grab a bite to eat, and I asked him about putting a reserve on the item since someone online had made an offer for $40,000. He told me that in his estimation, it wouldn't be a good idea because at auction, it would bring its true worth. He also said to me, "Wade...here's what's going to happen, when whoever offered you the 40 comes to see you, they are going to realize that you don't know a damn thing about stoneware pottery. Their going to tell you that from the photos, they couldn't see this and that and retract their offer of $40,000. Then they'll say that since they're here and it's still an OK piece, they will give you probably between $3000 to $5000, and guess what? You're going to take it." He couldn't have been any more accurate. He could have done the exact same thing for that matter, but that's not the kind of person he is or the kind of business he runs. I really enjoyed meeting him and felt like whatever it sold for would be the top dollar it could bring. On March 25th, it went up for auction and sold......for $76,000!!!!! I can't say enough about how grateful I am for Cagle Auction Company and especially Brandon Pratt. I only met him once, but we still talk every couple of weeks, and I know I'll call him a friend forever.  I have to say that this boy must piss excellence!! P.S. The piece of pottery is now in a museum in Williamsburg, Virginia

Why Choose Cagle Auction Co?

Honesty First

We are up front with fees and pricing at the beginning.

We Love What We Do

It’s not just our 9 to 5. Auctions are our passion.

Online & In Person

We auction on three online bidding platforms, and live in-person bidding to maximize top dollar.

Record Prices

Cagle Auction proudly holds many world record hammer prices throughout southern pottery, trains, and other antiques and collectibles.

In-House Shipping

We provide shipping in-house to carefully protect your valuable items while also saving you money every step of the way.

The Cagle Difference is our commitment to honesty, expertise, and results that speak for themselves.

Learn About The Cagle Difference

Record Hammer Prices

1950 Lionel Postwar Catalog W/ 773 Hudson Engine

World Record Price

1950 Lionel Postwar Catalog W/ 773 Hudson Engine

Hammer Price $80

View More Record Hammer Prices

A Message From Brandon Pratt

For the past 13 years, Brandon Pratt has been alongside Nathan Cagle for an amazing journey with this company.

It has been my greatest pleasure to have learned from one of the finest auctioneers this country has ever had. Ever since I was a young child, I always enjoyed collecting stoneware and energetically selling antiques. It all started at Williams Auction in High Springs, Florida, working with Red Williams and his son Charlie. I also have a passion for fishing and hunting as many of you know. I hold a USCG Captain’s License as well. It is with the same intensity I have for salt-water fishing that I approach the Auction Business. I seek to bring in the very best offerings with honesty, integrity, and exceptional customer service, all the while realizing top dollar for our clients.

That is the CAGLE DIFFERENCE.

It has been difficult for all of us at Cagle Auction since Nathan’s passing, but with determination and focus we look forward to the future as we continue to set records in the auction business. It is an absolute honor to be at the helm of Cagle Auction Company.

We will be delighted to see you all at the next auction!